“I had to be tough, I had to overcome, I had to be persistent and I had to pray.”
Claudio Reilsono’s 43 years in baseball have been shaped by rejection, unexpected opportunities, and a commitment to keep pursuing his dream. His experience offers a practical perspective on overcoming rejection: stay committed to the work, learn to recognize opportunity, build relationships with people who believe in you, and keep moving when the path becomes uncertain.
Overcoming rejection requires a person to keep believing in a goal when the evidence around them seems to suggest it is time to stop. For Claudio Reilsono, that test began early. At eight years old, after attending his first Pittsburgh Pirates game, he told his father he wanted to work in professional baseball. The dream stayed with him through failed playing opportunities, years of coaching, repeated job applications, and an eleven year wait for his first professional baseball position.
What keeps someone committed to a dream for decades?
Claudio’s ambition began with a specific moment at Three Rivers Stadium on August 19, 1973. The experience left such a lasting impression that he came home and told his father what he wanted to do with his life. His parents believed in him and promised to support his efforts.
That belief became an important part of his persistence. He wanted to make his parents proud, and he continued working toward professional baseball even when the route forward was unclear. Overcoming rejection became part of the journey, not a reason to abandon it.
How do you respond when a dream appears to be over?
Claudio remembers a final playing tryout where his performance fell short of expectations. His throws did not reach their targets, and he never got the opportunity to demonstrate his hitting. Sitting in the outfield afterward, he believed his playing dream was finished. He felt the weight of having to tell his parents that their belief in him had been misplaced.
For two weeks, he carried that disappointment. Then he considered coaching. He had already volunteered for five years, and at 23 he became head coach at his former high school. That decision gave his baseball career a new direction.
His experience illustrates an important part of overcoming rejection: disappointment deserves to be acknowledged, but it does not have to determine what happens next.
How can criticism become fuel for perseverance?
After winning a college championship in his first year as a head coach at age 25, Claudio expected professional opportunities to follow. They did not. Eleven years passed before he received his first professional job.
During that period, people questioned his ambition and told him to find a conventional career. Their criticism hurt, particularly when it came from people whose opinions mattered to him. Eventually, he learned to use those comments as motivation without accepting their judgment as the truth about his ability.
Claudio describes his approach through the acronym TOP: tough, overcome, persistent, and pray. His advice is to allow yourself to feel disappointment, then begin again.
Where can opportunity appear when the expected path closes?
After hundreds of unsuccessful job applications, Claudio noticed a small advertisement in The Sporting News for European baseball players. Because he spoke Italian and had extensive baseball experience, he contacted the Global Scouting Bureau to ask about possible work.
He stayed in touch with the company’s founder, James Gamble, for more than a year. Eventually, Gamble gave him an opportunity to organize and promote professional tryout camps. Claudio arranged facilities, promoted the events, and delivered the camps. That work led to a position with the organization, where he has now spent 25 years.
The opportunity came through persistence, initiative, and a willingness to take responsibility before a job was guaranteed. His advice is straightforward: opportunity does not always knock, so sometimes you have to call it up and invite it over.
What role do family and mentors play in pursuing a difficult goal?
Claudio credits his parents with giving him the belief and support that sustained his ambition. After his mother passed away, he considered leaving baseball. His father reminded him of the dream his mother had supported and encouraged him to keep going.
His wife Linda has also supported his ambitions throughout their marriage. When a coaching opportunity in Italy required a major family decision, she told him she would support the path he chose. Claudio ultimately declined the position after careful reflection, and continued building his career with the Global Scouting Bureau.
He also recognizes the impact of James Gamble, who gave him an opportunity when his professional background did not yet meet the usual expectations for the role.
What does it mean to lead from the heart?
Claudio’s book, Lead from the Heart Up, Not the Neck Up, reflects the philosophy he brought to coaching. He wanted players to know he cared about their lives, not simply their performance on the field. His aim was to help them learn how to handle life’s challenges as well as baseball’s.
He recalls former players who later became doctors and credited his guidance with influencing their lives. For Claudio, those relationships are evidence of the responsibility a coach carries. He believes people need to know that their leader genuinely cares about them.
He also emphasizes the importance of having the right people around a team. His championship teams required players who were receptive, committed, and willing to work together. He used the image of eating an elephant one bite at a time to help a struggling team focus on winning the next game and building momentum through achievable steps.
How do you maintain the relentless pursuit of winning?
Claudio believes persistence requires hard work, toughness, faith, and the willingness to keep pursuing opportunities. He also recognizes that effort must lead somewhere. When one path does not work, a person may need to find another way to apply what they have learned.
His own career moved from playing aspirations to coaching, scouting, speaking, media, and business ownership. Each stage brought relationships and experiences that shaped the next opportunity.
Overcoming rejection, in Claudio’s experience, means continuing to act with purpose after disappointment. Be good at your work. Build relationships. Ask for opportunities. Stay open to a new direction. And keep going.
• Keep a clear connection to the reason your goal matters.
• Give disappointment room, then decide what action comes next.
• Do not let someone else’s lack of belief define your potential.
• Create opportunities through outreach, preparation, and persistence.
• Recognize the people who support your growth and acknowledge their influence.
• Lead with genuine care for the people responsible for achieving the work.
• Build momentum through manageable steps and shared commitment.
• Stay open to new paths that allow your experience and abilities to keep developing.
Rick Meekins ( https://rickmeekins.com) is a serial entrepreneur, strategic business disruption advisor, podcast guest, and host of The Relentless Pursuit of Winning Podcast, where he explores what it actually takes to build, lead, and sustain meaningful businesses. With over 30 years of experience working alongside founders and leadership teams, Rick focuses on helping companies develop and implement disruptive advantages and developing platforms to explore and distribute human insight.
Interested in working together, having Rick speak, or partnering with the show?
Start here: https://rpowpodcast.com/contact/
00:54 Meet Claudio Reilsono
02:40 Ambition and Purpose
06:13 Making an Impact
08:49 Where the Dream Began
12:22 Success Without a Breakthrough
15:46 Handling Criticism
17:11 From Playing to Coaching
18:47 Breaking Into Pro Baseball
23:14 Finding Strength to Continue
26:44 Family Support and Tough Decisions
32:10 Leading from the Heart
36:08 Responding to Discouragement
37:33 Building Winning Teams
40:55 Finding Another Way to Win
43:44 Sustaining the Pursuit
48:21 Book and Closing Thoughts
Claudio Reilsono is completing his 43rd year in baseball and his 25th year with the Global Scouting Bureau. He recently retired as Head Baseball Coach at Carnegie Mellon University, where he spent 21 years and finished as the program’s all time wins leader. His teams won four collegiate championships across Penn State Beaver and Carnegie Mellon.
Claudio is also a speaker, author of Lead from the Heart Up, Not the Neck Up, and the owner of businesses spanning baseball training, media production, marketing, and landscaping.
“Lead from the Heart Up, Not the Neck Up: How to Create a Positive Winning Culture on the Field and in the Office”
Claudio’s book connects his coaching experience with his belief that leadership involves caring about people as well as helping them perform.
Learn more about the book and his leadership work at https://www.claudioreilsono.com/
Connect with Claudio